Interface comments

• All good, clear and neat.

---

Model comments

• Problem with crackling parameter , probably related to web-pd. By porting the model to javascript this should be fixed.


• The RTSFX sound is not snappy enough (see sound designers comments).


• Increase granularity and density of crackling and hissing would be good to acheive a more realistic sound.


• Differenciate left and right channels . Two differnt istances of the same model could be sent to the right and left channels, this would increase the naturalness of the model.


• It is possible to hear a loop related to the "hissing" parameter (see sound designers comments).

---

Sound designers comments

• The basic roar is good, however the hissing control introduces a sense of "looping". Crackling seems more random, but could have a more "snappy" edge like wood cracking in flames. The crackling element is the least realistic.


• Increase the cycle/randomness of the hissing element, add a "snap" control to introduce that sense of wood burning

Fire example, to use as general reference.

Medium Fire.

Large Fire

RTSFX syntheses - Recorded samples comparison.

RTSFX Fire Atmosphere (preset)

Sample Fire Atmosphere